The Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, which has shielded hundreds of thousands of young immigrants from deportation for over a decade, is facing renewed challenges in court as conservative states push for its termination.
For over a decade, the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program has allowed young immigrants, often referred to as “Dreamers,” to live, work, and thrive in the United States without fear of deportation. However, this long-standing protection is now facing its most significant legal threat yet, as a group of conservative states led by Texas seeks to dismantle the program in federal court.
The fate of DACA is currently in the hands of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, a court widely regarded as one of the most conservative in the country. On Thursday, a three-judge panel heard arguments that could determine whether the program, created by executive action in 2012 under former President Barack Obama, will survive. At stake are the lives of hundreds of thousands of young immigrants who have built their futures in the United States but now face an uncertain future.
DACA’s Origins: A Temporary Fix with Long-Lasting Impact
DACA was introduced in 2012 by then-President Obama as a temporary solution to protect undocumented immigrants who arrived in the U.S. as children. Referred to as Dreamers, these young people were raised in the country, often knowing no other home. The program was designed to offer them temporary relief from deportation while Congress worked on a more permanent immigration reform plan.
The legislative action, however, never came. Despite widespread bipartisan support for Dreamers, Congress has failed to pass comprehensive immigration reform that would address their legal status. In the absence of such legislation, DACA has continued to provide temporary protection, allowing recipients to apply for work permits, attend school, and contribute to the economy without the looming threat of deportation.
The program has proven to be immensely popular. At its peak, it had enrolled nearly 800,000 recipients, many of whom have since gone on to build successful careers in a variety of fields, from technology and education to healthcare. Today, approximately 500,000 Dreamers remain enrolled in DACA, their futures hanging in the balance as the courts debate its legality.
Legal Challenges: A Program Under Attack
From the moment DACA was introduced, it has faced legal challenges, particularly from conservative states. The primary argument against the program has been that its creation via executive action was unconstitutional, as immigration law falls under the purview of Congress. Critics of DACA have also argued that it incentivizes illegal immigration, encouraging more individuals to cross the border in hopes of benefiting from similar protections.
In 2017, then-President Donald Trump attempted to terminate DACA, arguing that it was an overreach of executive power. The move led to a series of legal battles, with courts reinstating the program in part, blocking its full termination, and allowing existing DACA recipients to continue renewing their status. However, the program has been closed to new applicants since 2021, leaving thousands of undocumented youth who would otherwise qualify for DACA without any protections.
The current legal battle began in 2018 when Texas and six other Republican-led states filed a lawsuit challenging the program’s legality. They argue that DACA imposes financial burdens on the states by requiring them to provide services to undocumented immigrants. The case made its way through the courts, ultimately landing before the Fifth Circuit, where Thursday’s arguments took place.
The Conservative Push: What’s at Stake
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, based in New Orleans, is known for its conservative leanings, making it a critical battleground for the future of DACA. In July 2021, U.S. District Judge Andrew Hanen of Texas ruled that the DACA program was illegal and ordered a halt to new enrollments, while allowing current recipients to maintain their protections as the case made its way through the appeals process.
Judge Hanen’s ruling was a significant blow to Dreamers and immigration advocates, as it echoed previous arguments that the Obama administration had overstepped its authority in creating the program. Hanen’s decision also found that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), which administers DACA, failed to follow the proper procedures when it implemented the policy.
The Fifth Circuit is now tasked with deciding whether to uphold or overturn Judge Hanen’s ruling. If the court sides with Texas and the other states, DACA could be effectively dismantled, ending the program entirely and leaving its recipients vulnerable to deportation. Such a ruling would likely send shockwaves through immigrant communities across the country and prompt an appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Dreamers in Limbo: Lives on Hold
For the hundreds of thousands of Dreamers who depend on DACA, the ongoing legal battle has created a climate of uncertainty and fear. Many recipients are deeply rooted in the U.S. and have built lives here, often with families of their own. They work in vital sectors such as healthcare, education, and technology, contributing not only to their local communities but also to the national economy.
A large portion of Dreamers are employed in frontline professions, including doctors, nurses, and essential workers who played critical roles during the COVID-19 pandemic. Losing DACA protections would not only jeopardize their personal livelihoods but also impact the industries they support.
Despite the program’s widespread popularity—polls have consistently shown that a majority of Americans support providing a path to citizenship for Dreamers—its future remains in doubt. The uncertainty surrounding DACA has left many recipients hesitant to make long-term plans, such as buying homes or pursuing advanced degrees, unsure of what their legal status will be in the near future.
Political and Social Implications
The fight over DACA is emblematic of the larger, long-standing battle over immigration policy in the U.S. While Dreamers have garnered significant public sympathy, immigration reform has remained elusive. Politicians on both sides of the aisle have called for action to protect Dreamers permanently, yet no legislation has successfully passed both chambers of Congress.
The debate over DACA reflects the broader divisions in American politics, with immigration serving as a key issue that deeply polarizes voters. Conservative states argue that DACA represents executive overreach and imposes undue burdens on state resources. Meanwhile, immigrant advocates and Democrats see the program as a moral and economic necessity, given the contributions Dreamers have made to American society.
As the court case proceeds, the Biden administration has expressed its support for DACA and has taken steps to fortify the program. In 2021, the administration issued a new rule aimed at solidifying DACA’s legal standing by addressing procedural concerns raised in previous court rulings. However, the legal challenges persist, and the ultimate decision now rests with the courts.
The Future of DACA: Uncertain But Critical
As DACA faces the most severe legal challenge in its history, the fate of the program—and the Dreamers it protects—remains uncertain. If the Fifth Circuit rules against DACA, it could be the end of a program that has provided vital protections to hundreds of thousands of immigrants for over a decade. Such a ruling would likely lead to an appeal to the Supreme Court, prolonging the legal battle and extending the uncertainty for Dreamers.
The outcome of this case will have far-reaching implications, not just for the individuals directly affected by DACA, but also for the broader debate over immigration policy in the United States. For now, Dreamers and their advocates wait anxiously, hoping that the courts will uphold the protections that have allowed them to build lives and contribute meaningfully to the country they call home.
In the meantime, the push for a permanent legislative solution remains as urgent as ever. The lives and futures of hundreds of thousands of Dreamers hang in the balance, awaiting a decision that could either solidify their place in America or force them into an uncertain and perilous future.
Related topics:
