Aidan O’Neill, a junior at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, along with two other students, had their study abroad plans abruptly canceled by the university just weeks before their departure. The decision came after the trio participated in an October 25 campus protest in support of Palestinians, resulting in their arrest and subsequent placement on disciplinary probation.
O’Neill, who was preparing to study abroad in Barcelona, expressed his disappointment, stating that losing his eligibility at the last moment was “heartbreaking.” The university’s move has left the affected students responsible for significant fees and travel expenses, forcing them to find housing and available courses on campus.
University spokesperson Ed Blaguszewski emphasized that the disciplinary measures were not related to the content of the October protest but were in adherence to existing policies. According to these policies, students on disciplinary probation for any reason are ineligible for UMass Amherst study abroad programs.
However, critics argue that the punishment faced by the students seems unusually severe, with concerns raised about potential infringement on First Amendment rights. The incident has prompted widespread support from UMass students, faculty, and alumni, urging the university to reconsider the disciplinary sanctions.
Rachel Mordecai, an English department faculty member and O’Neill’s adviser, penned a letter, co-signed by 23 other faculty members, expressing support for O’Neill. Jason Moralee, UMass Amherst associate dean of research and diversity, equity, and inclusion, also advocated for a swift resolution in support of the affected students.
Moralee, drawing from his experience as the former director of the UMass Oxford Summer Seminar, argued that peaceful protest by exemplary students should not prevent them from studying abroad. He called for an independent investigation into the disciplinary proceedings, questioning the fairness of the process and expressing concerns about bias and discrimination.
While UMass stands by its decision, the students affected by the study abroad restrictions are left grappling with the financial and emotional toll of the situation. One student, facing up to $20,000 in fees, is considering legal action against the university, asserting that UMass is infringing on their right to free speech. Experts note that proving a First Amendment violation in this context could be challenging, given the signed study abroad agreements and the need to demonstrate unfairness in the process.
